Monthly or yearly rebalancing? Compare the rule, not two different portfolios.
A reproducible two-portfolio setup for comparing monthly and yearly rebalancing with matching holdings and cash flows.
A controlled experiment
Use January 2016–December 2025, USD, a $10,000 lump sum, and two portfolios containing 60% SPY and 40% GLD. Set the first to rebalance every month and the second every 12 months. These are example instruments, not recommended allocations.
Loads example settings. Verify the assets before running.
What to inspect
- Compare final value and CAGR for the same observation dates.
- Switch portfolios in the asset-allocation chart. Notice when target weights are restored and how they drift between rebalances.
- Inspect rolling returns to see whether the ordering changes across windows.
- Repeat with rebalancing off and several start dates.
What this comparison cannot establish
The backtest does not include transaction costs, taxes or execution constraints. It therefore cannot establish which schedule would be best after costs for a specific investor. More frequent rebalancing is not automatically better.
Read Investor.gov’s explanation of allocation and rebalancing
Educational illustration, not investment advice or a forecast. Real markets fluctuate; taxes, transaction costs, and fees are not modeled. Change the dates and assumptions before drawing conclusions.
Choose the question you want to answer.
Worked examples & guides · Methodology & data · Future projections at Money Lab ↗